Skip to main content

Tampa Can Ban Cars (Like Utrecht Did)

My favorite Mark Wagenburr video on his channel Markenlei is the video titled Potterstraat, Utrecht (Netherlands).



In it, he describes how the historic city of Utrecht, Netherlands actually went down a similar path that the United States went down in the 40s and 50s. They, too, demolished their historic buildings to make way for a new transportation era dominated by cars. They, too, created grand city plans to endlessly widen streets to make way for the automobile. In fact, the buildings they so carelessly flattened were centuries old rather than decades old like the ones in America. This fact makes me feel a little less embarrassed about our country's car-centric development path.

However, the 1960s and '70s generation of Hollanders chose a drastically different path than ours did. In Utrecht, traffic continued to grow no matter how much they widened their streets. Life in the city center was simply awful, and this created a widespread a change of mind. So in 1965, they decided to ban cars on Saturday afternoons in the city center. It was so successful that in the early 1970s, they banned cars permanently from the city center.

Image result for when was cars banned from utrecht city center
A little "before" and "after" action for ya. Top pic is from 1965, bottom pic is from 2011.

That's right. They did it. They effectively banned cars. And they implemented several other magnificent, yet simple development policies as well. They reconstructed buildings in the right-of-way of roads they had previously widened, narrowing them back to their original width. They created bicycle paths separated from vehicular traffic by large medians with beautiful trees and landscaping in them to narrow streets and prioritize bicycle infrastructure. They lowered speed limits, blocked neighborhood streets to through-traffic, and poured raised pedestrian crosswalks all throughout the city.

They concentrated motor traffic where they wanted it to go, and they took back the streets for the people. We can do that too. We just have to demand it like they did in Utrecht. Perhaps we could start with a pilot project or "experiment" on a busy downtown street like Kennedy Blvd.


Popular posts from this blog

Stressed While Biking? Stress Maps Help Identify Infrastructure Priorities

I really enjoyed our second experiment with the TU Delft PhD students because I think it could be extremely useful to how we prioritize the development of bicycle infrastructure in my hometown. We created a rubric for grading the “stress level” of bicycle infrastructure, then we rode our bikes around town and "graded" different routes based on that rubric. This data can be used to create a bicycle stress map like the one pictured below. Some places, like Madison, Wisconsin, have created phone apps similar to Waze and Google Maps that allow people to choose a bike route based on the stress level of that route. Pictured is a stress map of Madison, Wisconsin.  We first split into groups. Each group generated a list of physical attributes of a street or route that might make a bike ride comfortable or stressful. For example, the type of bike lanes (if any) available, the width of the facility, the smoothness or bumpiness of the road, nearby greenery, traffic volume...

Some Discoveries About Equity in the Netherlands

Today I learned a few interesting things about disability and race equity in the Netherlands. Racism definitely exists here. Can't say I'm the least bit surprised, considering most of the people I have seen here have been white; well over 75%. I'm sure if I dug into the history and current political climate here, I'd find plenty of context. I also learned a bit about building public transportation with people in wheelchairs and mobility limitations in mind. Racism in the Netherlands Man who has lived in the Netherlands since he was four years old:  "If a person from say, Morocco applies for the same job as say, someone who looks like you or as a Dutch person, that company will definitely hire the Dutch person over the immigrant any day." Me:  "Do you not have a national law similar to the Civil Rights Act here which makes discrimination like that illegal?" Him:  "We do, but it is impossible to enforce. Nobody enforces it. They w...

Netherlands Redesign Project - USF Walk/Bike Plaza Between Leroy Collins Blvd and BullRun Drive

I have been working to push USF administration to embrace a bikable campus master plan for the past year with little success. Our final project for this class allowed me to think a little deeper about how I would redesign my least favorite/most frequented corridor on campus - the walk/bike sidewalk between BullRun Drive and Leroy Collins Blvd. See my group's final PowerPoint presentation here . During my first year as a Master of Urban and Regional Planning student, I lived in the Sunridge Palms Apartments on 50th Street, directly across from USF Elm Drive. I chose to commute to class by bike since I was less than a 0.5 miles from my furthest building, and I didn't even own a parking permit because I needed to save money as a broke grad student. The route I took everyday to class along USF Elm Drive to USF Apple Drive was the route I worked on for this project. It's the primary route that the thousands of students who live in housing on 50th Street take to access ...